Brainstorming has become something of a default in team meetings and workshops.

Many proponents of brainstorming believe that the unfiltered exchange of ideas can lead to groundbreaking solutions and that the energy generated in these sessions sparks innovation.

It promises open collaboration and unfiltered creativity, where everyone throws their ideas into the mix and “magic” happens.

But let’s be honest—how often does that magic really appear?

Research and real-world experience suggest that brainstorming often doesn’t live up to its hype.

For every loud idea that sticks, countless voices go unheard, groupthink takes hold, and the results end up feeling uninspired or incomplete.

If this sounds familiar, it’s time to rethink how we approach problem-solving and ideation.

Meet brainwriting—a silent, structured, and far more effective alternative.

Unlike brainstorming, brainwriting focuses on individual, silent idea generation, ensuring equal participation, fostering deeper independent thinking, and producing more diverse and innovative results.

At its core, it levels the playing field and invites every participant to contribute without fear of judgment or bias.

This article explores why brainwriting is superior to brainstorming, how it works, and how to integrate it into structured workshops to supercharge your team’s problem-solving and ideation capabilities.

What is Brainwriting?

Why Brainwriting Outperforms Brainstorming

The Research Behind Brainwriting

Why Brainwriting Thrives in Structured Workshops

How to Run a Brainwriting Session in Your Next Workshop

Exploring Variations of Brainwriting

Brainwriting Across Contexts: Adapting the Technique for Maximum Impact

Case Studies: Brainwriting in Action

Conclusion: It’s Time to Rethink Problem-Solving and Ideation

What is Brainwriting?

Brainwriting is a creative problem-solving and ideation technique that replaces loud group discussions with independent, written contributions.

The focus shifts from instant verbal exchanges to thoughtful ideation that happens in silence.

Each person writes down their ideas, which are then collected, shared anonymously, and collaboratively built upon.

Unlike brainstorming—where dominant personalities can overshadow quieter participants—brainwriting ensures that every voice is heard and every idea is judged on its own merit.

It’s not about who shouts the loudest; it’s about creating the space for every idea to shine.

The Brainwriting Process

A brainwriting session is a straightforward yet powerful method for generating a wealth of creative ideas.

While there are many variations of brainwriting, the following approach provides a solid foundation for unlocking your team’s collective creativity.

1️⃣ Preparation

Bring your team together and introduce the brainwriting process, ensuring everyone understands their role. Define the problem or topic clearly to focus the group’s creativity. For remote sessions, provide the necessary tools—whether physical or digital—as brainwriting works equally well in any setting.

2️⃣ Idea Generation

This is where the magic of brainwriting begins—generating ideas. Whether you prefer a fast-paced synchronous session or a more thoughtful asynchronous approach, this phase adapts to your team’s style and needs.

Synchronous: The session begins with participants silently writing down their ideas in response to the defined problem or topic. Whether on sticky notes, paper, or a digital platform, the focus is on generating as many ideas as possible without judgment or discussion. This step, lasting around 15 minutes, encourages quantity and unfiltered creativity.

Asynchronous: For teams that benefit from more time or independent work, asynchronous brainwriting offers a flexible alternative. Participants are briefed on the topic and given a day or two to generate ideas individually. These are then brought to the idea-sharing session, ensuring that everyone contributes thoughtfully.

3️⃣ Idea Sharing

Once all ideas are ready, they are shared with the group—either by posting sticky notes on a physical board or uploading them to a shared digital space. At this stage, participants read each other’s ideas silently, without interruptions or discussions, to allow unbiased consideration.

4️⃣ Idea Review

The final step is a collaborative review. Team members take time to reflect on the shared ideas, adding comments or building on them with their thoughts. This stage fosters a quiet yet dynamic exchange of creativity, turning individual contributions into collective innovation.

Why Brainwriting Outperforms Brainstorming

An article by Harvard Business Reviews titled “Why Group Brainstorming is a Waste of time?” found four reasons why brainstorming doesn’t work. These are;

⚠️ Social loafing: People tend to put in less effort in a group because they know others will contribute too.

⚠️ Social anxiety: Team members worry about how others will judge their ideas, especially if they feel less experienced.

⚠️ Regression to the mean: The most skilled participants end up lowering their performance to match the group’s average.

⚠️ Production blocking: Only one person can speak at a time, limiting the flow of ideas, especially in larger groups

What’s the take here? Brainstorming is chaotic, high-energy, and relies on group dynamics to fuel creativity.

But therein lies the problem: group dynamics often work against true innovation.

Here’s how brainwriting addresses these challenges:

The advantages of brainwriting over brainstorming aren’t just anecdotal—they’re backed by solid research. Here’s what the data tells us.

The Research Behind Brainwriting

Brainwriting isn’t just an alternative to brainstorming—it’s a scientifically validated improvement.

Several studies underline its effectiveness:

📋 Study 1: Reduced Production Blocking and Unique Ideas

“Idea Generation in Groups: A Basis for Creativity in Organizations” by Paulus & Yang (2000) in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology.

The Core Idea: It showed that brainwriting outperformed verbal brainstorming by reducing production blocking – where participants wait to share ideas – and promoting equal participation. The study also highlighted that independent writing led to more unique and innovative ideas.

Takeaway: Brainwriting allows for uninterrupted idea generation, ensuring all voices are heard.

📋 Study 2: Minimized Social Loafing and Structured Ideation

“Better than Brainstorming? Potential Contextual Boundary Conditions to Brainwriting for Idea Generation in Organizations” by Heslin (2009) in the Journal of Management.

The Core Idea: This study highlighted that brainwriting minimizes social loafing, reduces the influence of dominant personalities, and promotes more systematic and structured idea generation compared to traditional brainstorming methods.

Takeaway: Brainwriting makes sure that everyone participates equally which makes team innovation better.

📋 Study 3: Enhanced Idea Quantity and Quality

“Effectiveness of Brainwriting Techniques” in the Design Creativity 2010 Conference.

The Core Idea: This research compared different ideation techniques, including a hybrid 6-3-5 brainwriting method, to nominal groups (individuals working alone). The study found that groups employing the hybrid 6-3-5 method generated a higher number of ideas with comparable quality to those produced by nominal groups.

Takeaway: The hybrid 6-3-5 method (explanation below) increases the idea quantity and maintains quality.

📋 Study 4: Mitigation of Groupthink

“Oxford Handbook of Creativity and Innovation” by Paul B. Paulus and Bernard A. Nijstad

The Core Idea: This handbook examines various ideation techniques and notes that brainwriting can be more effective than traditional brainstorming under certain conditions.

Takeaway: Brainwriting minimizes groupthink by promoting independent thinking, making it a robust alternative to traditional brainstorming.

These findings underscore the advantages of brainwriting in fostering a more inclusive and productive ideation process compared to traditional brainstorming.

Why Brainwriting Thrives in Structured Workshops

Workshops thrive on efficiency and results.

Whether you’re solving a complex problem, ideating for a new project, or exploring potential solutions, brainwriting brings efficiency, clarity, and creativity to the process.

Here’s why it’s the perfect fit for structured workshops:

👥 Inclusive Participation: Brainwriting ensures that every participant contributes equally. In verbal brainstorming, louder personalities can overshadow quieter ones, resulting in a narrow range of ideas. Brainwriting eliminates this dynamic by giving every individual the space to think and contribute.

⭐️ Quality Over Quantity: While brainstorming often focuses on rapid-fire ideation, brainwriting emphasizes depth. Participants can think critically about their contributions, leading to ideas that are not only creative but also practical and actionable.

😵‍💫 Avoiding Bias: By anonymizing contributions, brainwriting removes personal biases from the equation. This means ideas are evaluated solely on their merit rather than who presented them. This helps create a more objective, fair, and open-minded approach to ideation

💻 Ideal for Remote and Hybrid Teams: As remote work becomes the norm, brainwriting is perfectly suited for asynchronous or virtual collaboration. Digital platforms like Miro, Trello, and Google Docs make it easy to gather and organize ideas, no matter where your team is located.

💡 Structured Yet Flexible Creativity: Brainwriting provides a clear process that keeps workshops on track, but it’s also flexible enough to adapt to different contexts. Whether you’re running a two-hour problem-solving session or a week-long innovation sprint, brainwriting scales seamlessly.

🎯 Delivers Actionable Results: Brainwriting isn’t just about generating ideas—it’s about refining and prioritizing them. By the end of the session, you’ll have a clear list of actionable concepts, ready for implementation.

How to Run a Brainwriting Session in Your Next Workshop

Integrating brainwriting into your workshops is simple, and the results can be transformative.

Here’s how to do it:

Step 1: Prepare and Define the Problem

Define the challenge or objective with precision. This helps participants focus on what matters most. Frame your challenge in a way that encourages creative thinking. For example, instead of saying, “We need to innovate,” try, “How can we improve the onboarding experience for new customers?”

Step 2: Choose Your Tools

Decide whether you’ll use physical tools (e.g., sticky notes) or digital platforms (e.g., Miro, Mural, FigJam). For remote workshops, digital tools are essential.

Step 3: Set Clear Expectations

Explain the process to participants, including time limits (5–15 minutes works well) for writing and instructions for building on others’ ideas. Emphasize the importance of independent thinking.

Step 4: Silent Idea Generation

Use the timeboxing method: set a timer and have participants write down as many ideas as possible. The key here is silence – no one is talking, no one is judging. Everyone is invited to think deeply about the problem and write down their thoughts. This can be done with pen and paper, sticky notes, or digital tools.

Step 5: Collect and Anonymize Ideas

The ideas are collected and anonymized if necessary (this removes personal bias, allowing ideas to be evaluated on merit rather than authorship), then shared with the group. For digital tools, platforms like Miro, Mural or FigJam enable seamless aggregation.

Step 6: Share and Build on Ideas

In this step, participants are encouraged to build on the ideas of others. By reading the ideas shared by their peers, they can expand or combine concepts to form even better solutions. This is where the collective intelligence of the group shines.

Step 7: Refine and Prioritize Ideas

Facilitate a discussion to refine ideas, combine similar concepts, and identify the most promising solutions. Use dot voting or ranking methods to reach consensus on which ideas to develop into actionable plans.

In the next section, we’ll dive deeper into the different variations of brainwriting and how they can be tailored to fit your team’s unique needs.

Exploring Variations of Brainwriting

Brainwriting is a versatile tool, and one of its greatest strengths is its adaptability.

Depending on team size, dynamics, and workshop objectives, different variations of the method can be employed to maximize results.

Each approach has its own structure and benefits, making brainwriting a flexible solution for a wide range of challenges.

Here are two notable techniques:

➡️ The 6-3-5 Method

The 6-3-5 brainwriting method is a structured yet dynamic way to generate a high volume of ideas quickly.

The numbers represent the process: six participants, three ideas each, and five-minute intervals.

In just 30 minutes, this method can produce up to 108 ideas, as stated in the study “Brainwriting vs. Brainstorming Case Study for Power Engineering Education”.

Here’s how it works:

1️⃣ Six participants each write down three ideas on a specific problem within five minutes.

2️⃣ After five minutes, they pass their paper to the next person, who reads the existing ideas and adds three new ones, inspired by the initial contributions.

3️⃣ This process continues until each participant has contributed to every idea.

The beauty of the 6-3-5 method lies in its structured flow. It builds momentum as participants draw inspiration from each other’s contributions, leading to a snowball effect of creativity.

➡️ The Brainwriting Pool

For a more flexible approach, the brainwriting pool offers participants the freedom to engage with ideas at their own pace.

Here’s how it works:

1️⃣ Participants write their ideas on individual sheets of paper and place them in a central “pool.”

2️⃣ Others can pick ideas from the pool, review them, and use them as a springboard for their own contributions.

3️⃣ This continues for a set period, allowing ideas to evolve naturally and organically.

The brainwriting pool is particularly effective when diversity is key. It removes the pressure of rapid ideation and lets participants browse through existing ideas to find inspiration. This freedom encourages out-of-the-box thinking and ensures a broad range of creative solutions.

Brainwriting Across Contexts: Adapting the Technique for Maximum Impact

One of the most compelling features of brainwriting is its adaptability.

Whether you’re working in business, design, or education, this method seamlessly integrates into various problem-solving scenarios, offering a structured yet flexible approach to idea generation.

Here’s how brainwriting shines in different domains:

📈 Business Applications

Brainwriting is a powerful tool for addressing a wide range of business challenges, from strategic planning to marketing innovation and operational improvements. Its inclusive nature fosters collaboration across departments, bringing diverse perspectives to the table.

For example:

➡️ A company planning a product launch could bring together team members from marketing, sales, and customer experience for a brainwriting session. Their combined perspectives might yield integrated strategies for promotions, advertising, and user engagement.

➡️ Similarly, teams could use brainwriting to identify solutions for operational inefficiencies or generate creative branding ideas, ensuring that every department contributes equally.

💡 Design and Creativity

Creativity lies at the heart of design, and brainwriting amplifies it by pooling individual ideas into collective innovation.

It can drive breakthroughs in various design disciplines:

➡️ Service Design: Streamline user-focused processes.

➡️  Product Design: Develop functional and aesthetically pleasing products.

➡️  Graphic Design: Create engaging visual communication concepts.

➡️  Interaction Design: Ideate intuitive interfaces that enhance user experience.

For example, a design team brainstorming features for a new app might use brainwriting to explore fresh solutions to common user pain points. As ideas are shared and built upon, the team can merge the best concepts into a cohesive design that meets user needs.

📚 Education and Learning

Brainwriting also thrives in educational contexts, both in classrooms and professional training. It’s an excellent way to foster collaboration and creativity among students and educators alike.

➡️ Teachers can use brainwriting to develop lesson plans or strategies for improving classroom engagement.

➡️ Students can apply it to group projects, using the process to generate topics, research methods, or even creative presentation ideas.

For example, a student team working on a group project might brainstorm research approaches using brainwriting. By pooling their ideas and iterating collaboratively, they can craft a strategy that reflects the strengths of every participant.

Regardless of the context, the core principles of brainwriting remain constant:

✅ Everyone contributes their ideas individually.

✅ All ideas are valued equally.

✅ Collective creativity drives the best solutions.

Its versatility allows brainwriting to be tailored to the unique demands of any field, making it a go-to strategy for innovation and problem-solving across industries.

Case Studies: Brainwriting in Action

Case Study 1: Marketing Campaign Strategy

Challenge: A marketing agency faced difficulty in breaking free from conventional ideas during campaign strategy sessions. Traditional brainstorming allowed dominant voices to overshadow others, stifling creativity.

Solution: The team adopted brainwriting in their next workshop. Each participant anonymously submitted five ideas, which were then shared and collaboratively discussed.

Outcome:

🎯 Over 50 unique ideas were generated, including bold and unconventional ones that traditional brainstorming would have missed.

🎯 One of these ideas was implemented by the client resulting in a 30% increase in campaign engagement.

Case Study 2: Product Development

Challenge: A product development team struggled with generating fresh ideas for their next release. Senior team members unintentionally dominated previous brainstorming sessions, resulting in uninspired and “safe” concepts.

Solution: The team switched to brainwriting during their next workshop. Over 30 minutes, participants anonymously submitted and built upon each other’s ideas.

Outcome: 

🎯 The team generated over 60 unique concepts, several of which led to innovative solutions that pushed creative boundaries.

🎯 One idea became a key feature in the product and received widespread customer praise.

Conclusion: It’s Time to Rethink Problem-Solving and Ideation

Brainwriting isn’t just a better way to generate ideas—it’s a smarter way to approach problem-solving as a whole.

By prioritizing inclusivity, structure, and creativity, it transforms meetings and workshops into truly collaborative spaces where the best ideas, not the loudest voices, rise to the top.

So the next time you’re tempted to reach for the whiteboard and start shouting out ideas, stop.

Instead, grab some pens, open your favorite collaboration tool, and give brainwriting a try.

You might just be surprised at what your team is capable of when everyone has the chance to think, write, and create.

Ready to build better ideas? Start with brainwriting.

Get in Touch

Do you want to transform your meetings or workshops into powerful, results-driven sessions?

Whether you’re looking to implement brainwriting in your ideation process, improve collaboration in structured workshops, or simply explore better ways to solve complex problems, we’d love to help.

Feel free to reach out! We’d love to discuss your upcoming projects and explore how we can support your goals.

Get Our Collaboration & Innovation Playbook for Free

Transform the way your team works with our free Collaboration & Innovation Playbook—a practical guide packed with proven methods to eliminate collaboration chaos, ignite creativity, and drive results.

Whether you’re leading meetings, running workshops, or managing remote teams, this playbook equips you with the tools to turn challenges into opportunities and ideas into action.

Ready to unlock your team’s full potential?